Yesterday, I read THIS POST by my friend, Greta.
Greta and I have met several times, we have a lot of the same friends, we read each other's blogs--and this week, we go to the same Vacation Bible School.
You really need to read her post, about the insecurities that women carry, and the unfair comparisons we hold ourselves to. Not to mention, the hormones and the HORMONES and the unnatural stretching of the _____________ (insert private part; ALL are appropriate). It's impossible (and semi-elastic), this business of being a woman.
But you really need to read it, because today I am going to give a voice to the Barbie. Not out of argument (because I admire her words) or offense--but simply because there are two (or 3 or 12) sides to every story. And those sides aren't always in disagreement.
Never in my life have I considered myself pretty. I'm average height, I'm not rail thin. In fact, I've majored in the art of "blending in" my entire life--which is an incredible feat when you are half-white in a practically Asian country (Hawaii) and half-Asian in a cornfield (Indiana). I did not draw attention to myself, good or bad--even though, as a teenager, I wanted to be the star of something/anything, because that's what high school rewards. You're either the best looking, or the best athlete, or the best student, or the best slacker, or you're everybody else. It's just the way the system works, and if you don't like it I suggest you join up with the Duggars. But also, and here's the secret--EVERYBODY hates the system. Well, unless you are the *exception*, the kid who is confident in their own skin, who understands sin and insecurity and the bigger picture that NO ONE WILL CARE if you were the head cheerleader when you are 35.
But for the purpose of this blog, I'm going to consider myself a Barbie. Not a tall blonde with legs up to my neck or anything, but probably of the groups of women of which Greta speaks. Let me be clear, IN NO UNCERTAIN TERMS, that I do not consider myself the type of girl that looks or acts as if I have my sh#! together on a daily basis. Quite the opposite. But I have gone to the church that sponsors this particular Vacation Bible Study for over 10 years. I am comfortable there, I have friends there. I did happen to wear workout clothes on numerous occasions during drop off this week (they were not made of spandex). I do get that I am an insider. And not in a way that's pompous or snotty--and DEFINITELY not in a way that takes offense to what Greta is saying. I'm just saying, with lots of awkward words and hand motions, that I get it.
I get it for a number of reasons, and this blog has made it very clear. You see, I DO NOT consider myself a Barbie (I don't think ANYONE woman with kids does, unless they are inebriated)--and yet, I'd be lying if I didn't say there weren't *comments*. Not the sweet kind that come from friends who tell you you look great (because you showered) or that your wearing a nice dress. FYI, if you give me those kind of comments I will say one of two things: 1.) Thanks! I showered today!, or 2.) Thanks! It's from Target! I do not take comments well, unless I can play them off on simple hygiene, or prove, with receipts, that my looks cost less than $10. Fact.
Want to make me SQUIRM OUT OF MY SKIN? Tell me I am a good writer. That's the kind of compliment I CANNOT handle.
No, the kind of comments I am talking about, in regard to "Barbie-ness" are of this variety:
"I read your blog and it's so great! But I just can't read it anymore, because the stuff you do with your kids makes me feel like a terrible mother."
Wow.
Friends, that's what we are now going to refer to as "The Barbie Bitch Slap". There are no words that sting quite as good as those. To do something you love with your kids, something that drives you creatively--and to be told that the simple act of being good at something makes other people feel terrible. It can be your looks, it can be your talents, it can be the way you mother, it can be the way you eat broccoli. WHATEVER. I am a firm believer that women shouldn't have to apologize for being good at something. For being the Barbie of anything. People who wear monograms have feelings (and insecurities) too.
That last sentence was sarcastic. HALLELUJAH, I have my sarcasm back.
Now, where was I.
Right. So, I write this here blog, and I do share some of the things that I make or do with my kids (not all, because you can't handle that kind of AWESOME...kidding). Do you only see the side of me that acts like Martha Stewart, or are you reading that I am in the middle of major family changes that are threatening to send me into code-red-mental-breakdown if that damn house doesn't sell SOON??? Do you think that I am shallow because I like my children to wear (matching) shirts that I applique? Do you think that because I exercise that I am self absorbed? Or are you reading (gross) tales of the things growing on my feet, the 60 pounds I gained with EACH pregnancy and the stash of post-natal pads I recently parted with?
I think I am very real about the things that are, well...REAL. You get both good and bad here. But it can't be just one-sided, because ladies, LISTEN UP. We're all good at something. We were created in the image of God, and he aint mediocre. And we need to own that. And love what we do, and who we are. And not apologize for it. And not compare the strengths of others. We are created to be a body, different in our gifts and talents. THE BIBLE SAYS SO.
I had FIVE children in three years. FIVE. When Little J was born, G was only 3, and there was that whole cluster of premature, one-year-old twins. I have been stretched and scarred. I have worn a Size 14 and a Size 4. I've been on bedrest twice and been force-fed Jimmy Dean sausage sandwiches (barf). I've lived those crazy baby years on a much, MUCH abbreviated schedule, and I've survived! Ladies, you will SURVIVE! And one day, you will get to shower whenever you want. And grocery shop anytime you like, when ALL the kids are in full-day school. You'll be able to exercise anytime you want, without feeling like you are sacrificing your only free minutes to aerobic torture. You will be able to go to the pool and not feel like someone is going to die. Resist the temptation to compare yourselves to other mothers; we walk in different stages, at different times. We ALL pay our dues. We are all puked on and yelled at and whined at and sleep deprived at some point--that is the privilege (sarcasm) that comes with being the most constant and trusted things in the world of our little people.
I have lots of Barbie friends that I love. And you know what? I try to be intentional with them, because in my experience, women treat Barbies BADLY. With jealousy and distrust--and with so much insecurity that they assume these seemingly perfect women would never want to be friends with someone less groomed. And just to be clear (again), I consider myself of the less groomed variety. I've known so many women who are so humbly beautiful, and so completely misunderstood. Held at a distance, because no one likes that kind of comparison. I have Barbie friends that are really successful at their jobs, but feel alienated from the stay-at-home-mom crowd. I have Barbie friends who have gobs of money, but are incredibly insecure at the kind of attention that brings. You name it, Satan has an AWESOME talent for turning our gifts and talents and blessings into poison for our relationships.
Resist.
Again, this is not meant as a rebuttal, or an argument against what Greta is saying--instead, more of a virtual conversation? Because really, I think we're kind of saying the same thing? No? Thoughts? Barbie Bitch Slap?
20 comments:
i think you're saying the same thing... and i love the conversation between 2 women i admire. because i feel like greta does- sweaty, hassled, losing julia (didn't you & mike help me find her in the reptile house at the zoo?!) and forgetting the papers i was supposed to sign. but then i am told that i'm intimidating- that my _____ makes someone feel bad about themselves, or my life looks perfect from the outside. i work at maintaining appearances, for sure- but i also try to be real. maybe this is why i take pictures of the exploded tomatoes in my kitchen and the jungle of nastiness under my couch... i'm not barbie, and i really don't want anyone to believe that i am.
Where to put myself is what i am left wondering. Am i a barbie because i wore spandex to pickup yesterday and drive a big (used) suv that, yes, i monogrammed. (out of pure joy to have gotten rid of my minivan!) or because my kids have FINALLY reached the stage where it is (slightly) easier to get them loaded and unloaded from the car? Or am i a mess because i have spent my whole adult life battling the same fifteen pounds, fed my family pb and j for dinner last night and am sure that i look nothing like barbie and just generally look "weird". I guess what i am trying to say is really we are all a bit of both, and we may just be the opposite of what we appear?
I'll weigh in because I admitted to feeling just the way Greta did at VBS last summer. And I hate that I so easily resort to the comparison game when I'm someplace new and around people I don't know. Why do we do that? And by the way, the comparison goes both ways. If I had pulled into a parking lot full of motorcycles with car seats strapped to the back I would have been feeling pretty damn good about myself...but probably would have assumed I'd be the most square mom there and then felt like I needed to prove I was more edgy than I am...and so it goes. I know I pray that God will help me see myself the way He does and I pray that God will help me see people I judge to be terrible the way He does. I guess I need to pray that He change the way I see everyone.
Somehow God has blessed me with an inability to keep my mouth shut which leads to me getting in hot water and feeling like I can never show my face at VBS again. I went deeper yesterday and posted this:
http://gremadcha.blogspot.com/2011/06/vbs-upon-reflection.html
Let me tell you I am awesome at laying it all out there. Anyway, I do think we are saying the same thing. Being a mother is a ridiculously hard job and my being snotty about fancy cars and what size you are doesn't help. It's easier for me to go there than where all the REAL hurt is. As stated in yesterdays blog post, which should probably be handed out and next weeks Greentree service so I am not shunned forever and ever. My kids REALLY dig your VBS.
Somehow by watching T.V., vaccinations with mercury, magazines? I was programmed to believe that size small and money mean MORE AWESOME AND THEREFORE TO BE HELD IN GREATER ESTEEM THAN I WITH A HEALTHY DOSE OF FEAR. Silly really, right?
P.S. You can bet your ass if someone gave me a whole pile of money and I lost weight I would be wearing spandex in my brand new 2012 Honda minivan WITH AN ENTERTAINMENT SYSTEM.
Call me shallow. It would be true.
I love both posts, because we have all been there. We all have insecurities and we have all made someone else feel insecure. I love the reminder that we were created in his image and we are supposed to be great and amazing. We forget that all too often and hide behind our pride disguised as self- degradation. Let me just say again that I love this blog and how "real" you keep it.
Nice work nak. Beautifully said.
What great thinking, Sara. There is no doubt that Satan is out to tank the self-esteem, joyful spirits and deep relationships between women because they are the keepers of the hearts of the children. Tank the Moms and get the kids as a bonus. It's sort of his game plan, I think.
As Oprah reminds us, you have to name it to claim it, so this conversation puts it out there, gives it a name and allows Moms to work through it all together.
And you are a great writer, so there. My proof? Numerous sentences from this post could be used as evidence, but I prefer this one: "Friends, that's what we are now going to refer to as "The Barbie Bitch Slap.""
i like this post and linda's comment is spot-on. this just reaffirms what i have always thought, that vbs is satan's workshop for bringing out the worst in moms.
I love the phrase "pride disguised as".....you fill in the blank
recently humility was discussed and it was determined that it was NOT thinking less of yourself BUT
thinking of yourself less
We "are all meant to be good at something" but we should NEVER use the "C" word!!!
SARA, YOU ARE AN AWESOME WRITER! (yes, I DO know that I'm yelling!)
Love what you and Greta both said! I too struggle with the same temptations to compare. As my wise friend Jen Hahn says "Comparison is thief of joy" This statement has freed me in so many ways to be a better mother, wife, and friend. I wrote some thoughts last year that you can read (if you're so inclined). http://muehleisenfamily.blogspot.com/2010/08/mommy-porn.html
Beautiful post. So true. I have been so insecure around other women throughout my life that I simply waited and always made friends with whoever approached me (barbie or not). The problem with that approach is that I have probably missed out on some friendships because we were both standing at opposite ends of the room busy being insecure. How crazy is that!
I love you because you are so very real. And no I could never pull off half the things you do with your kids, but somehow your tone never makes me feel insecure.
I was thinking sort of the same thing about Greta's post, that it has a lot to do with the stage of life you're in and how old your kids are. Because I felt like a giant loser for years when I never bathed and always wore mismatched (daywear with nightclothes) clothing. My kids are 9/6/6/4, which is a world away from Greta's 7/5/3/baby. It doesn't look like a lot written down, but WOW that's a massive difference.
This is a great topic.
Thanks for writing about this. I loved reading both posts b/c I (like most moms)have felt on both sides of the fence. I love looking nice and doing fun crafty things, but the thought of doing crafts w/a 3 year old son makes me feels like pouring lemon juice on paper cuts. My house is not immaculate, but I like to pretend it is. None of us is perfect, but it is so easy to jump to conclusions about other moms/women. It's part of how we're programmed I think. Great discussion ladies.
I've never commented before, but am an avid reader of your blog. I seriously look forward to every post because you always make me laugh out loud. You ARE a fabulous writer and I aspire to be more like you when I write. I've had a rough week with my kids and with just life in general. This post really hit home with me and, I admit, made me a little weepy. Thank you. Please don't ever stop writing, it's very clear to me that it's one of the things God put you on this earth for. Seriously!!
Do your children enjoy VBS?
Hey Anonymous--My children have loved every second of VBS. All kinds of excitement over what they are doing, lots of retention of what they are learning. It is phenomenal, one of the best things our church does for it's children's program. Our insecurities as moms should NEVER, EVER threaten what's being taught to our kids there. It is priceless.
The day I looked the nicest (had to go into work) I realized I forgot to brush my teeth. And I only have 1 kid. Whatevs.
I just absolutely loved both posts. I live no where near any of you (I'm in Dallas, land of big cars, bigger breasts, and big hair) but I can relate. I grew up with a judgemental mom and it is now natural to compare myself to other moms, other women, others in my business. And judging and comparing are certainly satan's tools to try to make us feel less than.
I now work full time, am a divorced mother of two (11 and 9), drive a min(van) with just shy of 100k miles with some sort of goo spilled between the middle seats that my kids neglected to tell me about until it was too late to clean up easily, hair that is grey, long, stringy and doesn't know what it wants to be when it grows up, and a rear that is far too wide but is swathed in spandex when I run my half marathon, train for it, and just about any other time I don't have to be in work or church clothes.
I hoard fabric and feel guilty about it (satan). I overeat and feel guilty about it (satan). I fuss at my kids for x, y and z and feel guilty about it (sometimes) (satan). I feel like I'm left out and left behind many groups of moms and never feel like I fit in (almost certainly satan whispering sweet nothings in my brain while I sleep).
You both put it into words I couldn't.
Sara, (or is it Sarah?), I found your blog from Rants and went back and read all the way from the beginning. You were brought into my life just as I was struggling with gifting God to my children, being the best mom God intended me to be, and being a good friend. I'm pretty sure it wasn't coincidence.
Please keep writing because you rock!
Wow! I go out of town to the land of no internet and come home to find THIS debate/discussion/whatever. Love it!
MY issue is that YES there are ways each of us may or may not intimidate other women (talents especially) BUT to add wealthy and thin to an already talented woman is just too much for me. And if I'm being totally honest, you intimidate the hell out of me. Most women do. Here I am, chubby and living with my parents while most women I know have either enough money to be stay at home moms or killer jobs they love (that make oodles of cash). AND are thin. I know it's stupid but it's impossible, for ME, to not look to you as someone I can't measure up with. Living in a neighborhood I could never afford with time+energy to do all the crafts I dream of AND a rockin cute body! :) BUT. Luckily, I am really good at pretending to not feel completely insecure. When I have to. And other times I just stay distant. Which is so stupid because I bet I could have so many amazing friends I'm missing out on because of insane insecurities!
SO.
For the last six months or so I've been trying to adapt Adriane's "comparison is the thief of joy" and it's really been helping! She's brilliant! Or Jen is! :)
AND.
Sara, comparison or not, I think you're amazing. NOT because of where you live or how you look but because of who you are. The mother you portray to the world, the way in which you capture your day with each perfect word, your hilarious honesty and the intensity with which you love. Thanks for this blog post, as one who suffers from Barbie envy I needed to read it!
Sara I dont know u personally but I'm posting here bc Greta keeps deleting my cmoment. I think a lit if what Greta said and the comments are divisive and hurtful. Things like: "that's why riverside doesn't have vbs" and "that's why I live in Webster" blah blah blah buoy can say your just being honest but what are the women you speak of supposed to say "this doesn't cut deeply bc they are just being honest!" I don't think so. I think it hurts and than makes people feel bad about themselves all bc others so quickly judged the mon that's cute or has a nice car. It's sad and it's what I hate most about being a woman. And it's not ok. I was just enjoying vbs and felt knocked over by all this. It made me not want to go bc others obviously hated me.
Post a Comment