Thursday, February 2, 2012

I've really had enough with the over-arching statements of hatred.


This is a post I want/ don’t want to write, in equal measure.  Because it’s scary, and it means we need to talk politics, and in my opinion, politics lead NOWHERE good.  Let’s be clear, I am NOT HERE to ram something down your throat--so if at any point you feel the desire to punch me in the face, please, PLEASE, remember that this comes from a good, if somewhat ill-communicated place.

And deep breath.

Let me tell you something about who my husband and I are:  

We are parents raising four kids--sometimes well, and sometimes unconventionally, and sometimes disastrously.  We live in middle America, Missouri.  We own our own business, and at times it is awesome, and at times it is so complicated, that we want to get rid of everything we have and move to the rainforest.  Scratch that, the beach (no snakes, killer tan).  We have lived in a really nice house on a golf course, and now we want LESS.  We have known incredible struggles.  We are Christians.  We are conservative.  We vote Republican.  

We have NEVER once put a political sign in our yard.  EVER.  Because we believe that the *politics* of putting a sign in your yard has become...passive-aggressively, ugly.  This isn’t always the reason people do it--so RELAX, those of you who are showing your support for Uncle Steve who is running for State Senate--but in my experience, signs come with a kind of hostility.  They are polarizing.   We don’t make it our business, or our general theme in life, to point out the DIFFERENCES we have with our neighbors, and despite even our best intentions, that is what the signs do.  Placed even in innocent support or void of malice, these sorts of things breed stereotypes and untruths and prejudices--and we just believe we can be Republicans without them.

We don’t watch Fox News.  GASP!  We actually can’t handle Fox News, it gives us the shakes.  Not because we disagree with it’s content, but we just really can’t stand people whining ALL. THE. TIME.  Honestly, I tell my kids to knock that sh#! out, so I certainly am not going to listen to it during the two hours I have to relax and unwind at night.  No thankey, and that goes for you too CNN, and MSNBC, and all your counterparts.   I am no political expert, but I educate myself when I feel like I need to, and I am confident that I know WHERE to find information.   The Internet seems to have a lot of it.  The economy sucks, unemployment rates suck, the real estate market sucks--I don’t need to hear about whose *alleged* fault it is.  I KNOW who’s to blame--I AM, because I am selfish and ego-centric, and there is a part of me that thinks I deserve everything I want.  We are ALL part of the problem, friends--and this is the Christian part of me that believes we are DESTINED to screw this up.  The Bible tells me that, but even if you think the Bible is a load of crap, can you REALLY argue that this isn’t what human beings do--just look at history.  Tell me who has gotten it right?

Which brings me to my point--the things that people are posting on Facebook and Twitter, regarding the Komen’s Foundation’s decision NOT to support Planned Parenthood.  Good golly.   I am conservative, I am pro-life--I am not a woman-hater, I am NOT out to destroy the freedom of my gender.  You can tell me I am, but I can assure you, I’m not.  I do not bomb abortion clinics, or yell and condemn the women who visit them.  I HURT for them, I’m terribly saddened by the circumstances that got them there, and for the scars they will carry for a lifetime.  I would like to make them candy covered pretzels and craft a flower out of felt for them, because this is my love language.  Or give them a hug, if I was a hugger.   I LOVE a handful of women that I know personally, who have had abortions--all of them as teenagers--who came to their decisions out of a place of desperation.  I HATE that young girls AND grown women have to face that kind of fear.  I do not think I am any better than someone who has struggled with this decision.  When Mike and I were expecting our triplets and my water broke with our son Caleb, we were given the option of “aborting” one son, for the sake of Big J and L--and no matter what side of the fence you sit on, that kind of responsibility is enormous, and the weight of those words is heavy and sad.  And this is coming from a woman with the support of her husband and family, with the resources to care for her children and to seek medical care.  I am devastated for women who have to make that choice in secret, and who hide that kind of pain for years, or lifetimes because they fear judgement.  I am pro-life, I do not believe that abortion is the only choice under terrible circumstances; but I don’t believe that not having an abortion means I am going to heaven and that all pro-choice advocates are morally corrupt, baby killers who are going to hell.   

I think the Susan G. Komen Foundation has done AMAZING things for women’s health.  I think they’ve rallied a nation behind a deeply, personal cause and that they care so much about what they do, that they are REALLY good at raising money to support it.   I also think, that at the end of the day, that kind of money breeds distrust, and that’s incredibly sad.  I’ve heard arguments, years before this sh#! storm, that the attention brought to breast cancer awareness tends to take focus and funds away from some of the other cancers.  Jealousy between life-threatening cancers is the bottom of the barrel, I think.  As is taking the spirit of a non-profit organization who’s desire is to do GOOD, and telling them they are worthless, spineless, political pawns.  I would LOVE to say this isn’t political, and at the heart of breast cancer awareness, I don’t think it is--but there isn’t a company or organization on the planet that can raise that kind of money and have that kind of attention placed upon them, that won’t be turned political.  With their success, comes THOUSANDS of opinions about HOW they should spend that money and where it should go, and a critical distrust of how they carry themselves.  They are DESTINED to leave someone empty-handed, certain to come up short, no matter what their budget.  There is NEVER enough, friends.  They are trying to cure cancer and they STILL can’t please everybody; even worse, they are inspiring actual, seething hatred.  

Which is where the Facebook propaganda really gets me.  I think the Komen Foundation has the right to fight cancer the way they see fit.  I stand by their choice, I think the world is a better place for the work that they do, and that doesn’t make me ignorant, or an anti-feminist, or someone who wants to see underprivileged women die of cancer--I just have a different opinion.  I didn’t vote for President Obama, and I don’t agree with some of his policies--but I’m not going to call him an idiot and spew hatred at him every chance I get.  I freaking hate that--oh, that makes my blood boil.   What a way to teach our kids how to be divisive and hostile and stubborn, because they HEAR that, friends.  I am certainly *trying* to model respect, for the simple fact that he is the PRESIDENT of the UNITED STATES--even when it’s the more popular choice to jump on an incredibly immature bandwagon.  Whether I voted for him or not, I am under his authority, because that’s how this country works and I am welcome to go elsewhere.  But I rather like it here, and if I REALLY want to change things, I am welcome to DO SOMETHING about it, create a foundation to raise money and awareness, run for Congress--you name it.  Except that I generally choose to watch the Kardashians against ALL OF MY BETTER JUDGEMENT, and that is further proof that I AM the problem with this country.    

You all are welcome to discuss this with me.  RESPECTFULLY.  Because I can love you all, and deeply appreciate you--and we can STILL be different.  I am okay with that.  I will still laugh at your jokes and cherish your comments, even if we disagree--but probably not if you YELL your seething hatred of me (in all caps, fyi--that’s internet speak for screaming).  I will try, but it’s gonna hurt a little, and I’m gonna cry, and then I’m gonna write a sarcastic response.  

22 comments:

Patti said...

Beautifully written

Bob said...

SARA....Patti is correct..."beautifully written"

Love You

mdenckhoff said...

Possibly your best yet!

carol said...

I "heard" your heart as you used a bigger font...I also feel like hugging you right now :)

Jess said...

AMEN!

Becky said...

I feel the same way but reading this makes me anxious about the hostility that lies ahead w election year. Hate it when that's all "mature" adults want to discuss bc I'm just not that mature.

Katrina said...

Love it!!!

Becky Hauser said...

Amazing!!! Read this about an hour ago and I'm still thinking about all of it. You summed up what most adults are not able to truly admit.

Pete Scribner said...

Thank your so much for sharing your thoughts. I found myself whispering "Amen" time and again as I read it, both in regards to your point of view and for the refreshingly non-contentious way in which you present it.

Oh, that we all (liberal, conservative or whatever else we may be) might take part in such discourse as opposed to the angry rhetoric to which both sides so commonly resort. I only hope others are listening as well as you have spoken.

Tammy said...

Thank you so much for a wonderfully written post. You were able to write so many of the things that are rolling around in my head on a daily basis.

Dawn Livingston said...

inspired...

Susan said...

An amazing post. So well written and SO very true. I am right there with you! My very best to you and your family.

Anonymous said...

I disagree with every conclusion you reach in this post but respect, admire and to some degree agree with your experience and reasoning behind each. I am equally disillusioned by the 'hate politics' going on and while I have opposite political opinions, I really respect and appreciate the non-contentious way you present your perspectives. Thank you.

libryan said...

We are one person. I have been trying to bite my "FB tongue" on the Obama issue for over a month. As Christians, I cannot see how to justify "spewing hate" on the person who we are called to be under authority. Don't get me started on the fact that these same people were screaming "un-American" to the liberals who spewed hate on Bush. And I have actually curbed my FB addiction for a few days until this Planned Parenthood thing dies down....I may have to leave until post-election.

ErinVB said...

The juicing and vegetarian diet is making you smarter!! Love this post so much.

Tiffany said...

Fabulous post.

JenHahn said...

I'm not sure I agree with your conclusion about the signs. I think they are no more or less polarizing than announcing that one is a Republican. If people support a candidate, they should show their support. It can open up discussion with neighbors who may not have decided, especially in local elections. But, I do agree with your sentiment that looking out for #1 (ourselves) is what's wrong with the world. That mentality is difficult to change, so how do you manage the effects of the sinful heart on a nation-wide and even global scale? We are so blessed to have the chance to vote for the person who might manage the mess in a way that we might if we had all the money and connections the politicians do. Do we have to be rude and ugly, no. But it's great that people are passionate about what they think might make our country better....and I might be more passionate, too, if my kids would actually sit through the news...or I followed politicians on Pinterest.

Eric Hauser said...

An excellent perspective Sara. No matter which side of the isle you favor, there is no rational reason to project the extreme, hate-filled opinions that dominate all forms of media lately. I, like you, consider myself a Republican, but find myself equally repulsed by each party during these progressively longer election years (I mean, is it really ONLY February?).

Gina Dankel said...

This is so great. I unfortunately missed this post yesterday! I fully agree with everything you said. I didn't know what was going on b/c I only saw 2 f/b posts regarding this. I guess that probably means most of my friends are similar to me? Not sure that's a good thing, but I think I missed most of the F/B anger.

Michael and Rachelle said...

Wow! Well said!

Kelly Grant said...

Well said. Thank you for this post.

Thank goodness for crafting when we all have to face these heavy topics, right?

Karen Cordano said...

Yesterday I found your blog through the comment you left on the OMG I'm a Mom blog. I loved what you wrote, it would seem we have a very similar parenting philosophy, one I don't live up to all the time, but I'm trying.

This post is incredibly thoughtful and I agree with a lot of it. Full disclosure: I say that as a liberal and a registered democrat.

And while I didn't post anything on FB about the controversy I did virtually sign a petition and I agreed with a lot that was posted. Vitriol is never the answer, but in this case I was heartened and proud that public outcry led to a positive change.

Yes, I am pro-choice. But honestly, this issue is not about abortion to me. It is about cancer screening for poor women. Right now the infrastructure for reaching these women is through Planned Parenthood. By taking funding for breast cancer screening away and not addressing the gaping hole that leaves the Komen foundation was not being true to their mission. They are not a pro-life foundation. They are a cancer foundation.

I am excited that social media was used to both effect change in their policy, and to expose their hypocrisy. At the same time I am not proud of the name calling and hatred. But I am proud to be an American. I believe America and Americans are better than the lunatic fringe on both sides.

And I respect you and your positions. I think if we met in real life we'd have a lot to talk about and might even become friends. You are clearly a very thoughtful person, and that quality is one of my favorite things no matter if you are liberal or conservative.